Dilara Hamit
20 November 2026•Update: 20 November 2026
Schools requiring students to lock away their cellphones recorded modest improvements in math and reading growth equivalent to one to two additional weeks of learning each year, according to a Harvard-led study.
Researchers at Harvard University’s Center for Education Policy Research, Dartmouth College and testing organization NWEA analyzed data from approximately 3.3 million students attending 4,600 US schools between the 2021-22 and 2025-26 school years.
The report, released Tuesday, examined changes in achievement growth after schools introduced strict bans using lockable pouches.
The researchers estimated an annual improvement of about 0.01 standard deviations in math and reading. They translated that measured gain into the equivalent of one to two weeks of additional instruction.
The findings suggest small annual improvements could accumulate over time, although the authors said schools should not expect an immediate large increase in achievement.
The analysis compared growth before and after the introduction of pouches with growth in comparison schools. Researchers reported no systematic differences in their achievement-growth trends before the bans.
The study also found fewer students experiencing large annual losses in reading, without clear evidence that gains were greater among students who initially scored lower.
Harvard education economist Thomas Kane said in a university interview that the scale of the gains was small compared with interventions such as tutoring, but potentially meaningful if sustained.
He said keeping phones physically out of reach could reduce dependence on individual teachers to enforce restrictions.
The researchers also examined statewide restrictions introduced in 22 states during 2025-26. Those findings were less conclusive because states adopting bans had different achievement trends beforehand.
Evidence from other research remains mixed.
A separate national working paper published by the National Bureau of Economic Research found average effects on test scores were close to zero. That study reported modest positive effects in high schools, particularly in math, and small negative effects in middle schools.
The Harvard report used individual students’ growth on a common assessment, while the earlier study analyzed school-level results from different state tests.
Kane said the effects of cellphone and social media use outside school remained an important unanswered question, requiring better data linking usage patterns with academic outcomes.